Hello Everyone!
This blog is a part of the Flipped Learning activity on Arundhati Roy’s novel The Ministry of Utmost Happiness, assigned by Dilip Barad Sir for the course Post-Graduate English Literature: Contemporary Indian Fiction. The objective of this task is to move from passive reading to active literary creation, using AI tools to analyze the complex narrative, characters, and themes of the novel.
Through this flipped classroom activity, we first explored the video lectures by Prof. Barad, which helped us understand the non-linear narrative structure, character backstories, and the significance of key locations such as Khwabgah, Jantar Mantar, the Graveyard (Jannat Guest House), and Kashmir. The novel presents a fragmented world where gender identity, caste politics, state violence, and national conflict intersect, and each character contributes to redefining the meaning of “Jannat” (Paradise) for the marginalized.
In this blog, I will critically examine how Roy’s “shattered story” technique reflects the trauma and resilience of her characters, especially Anjum, Saddam Hussain, and Tilo. I will also analyze the themes of modernization, motherhood, displacement, and resistance, showing how the graveyard becomes not a space of death, but a living paradise for society’s rejected people.
This blog includes the outcomes of the assigned AI-assisted activities — such as the textual analysis of the shattered narrative (Activity A), the character-location mind map (Activity B), the automated timeline of character arcs (Activity C), and the audio-visual thematic synthesis (Activity D). Together, these activities help present a multimedia critical reflection on Roy’s vision of survival, dignity, and inclusive humanity. For more infornmation Visit Sir's Blog:
Part 1: The Ministry of Utmost Happiness – Khwabgah
Part 2 | Jantar Mantar | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness – Characters & Conflict
This lecture (Part 2 of a series on The Ministry of Utmost Happiness) focuses on the scenes and characters associated with Jantar Mantar, a major protest site in New Delhi that represents political dissent and social struggle. The instructor explains how Arundhati Roy shifts the narrative from the more intimate, community-based world of Khwabgah (in Part 1) to the public and political arena at Jantar Mantar, where issues of caste, state violence, and civil rights come to the forefront. This part of the story broadens the novel’s scope from personal identity struggles to national political conflicts, showing how the personal is political in contemporary India.
This lecture focuses on two deeply symbolic elements in Arundhati Roy’s The Ministry of Utmost Happiness: Udaya Jebeen and the dung beetle, both of which represent resilience and marginalized existence. Udaya Jebeen is one of the “Miss Jebeens” whose life becomes central to understanding how abandoned or socially invisible children embody the emotional core of the novel. Through her story, Roy highlights themes of loss, displacement, identity, and survival, showing how fragile lives are shaped by violence and neglect in contemporary India.
The lecture explains that Roy uses Udaya Jebeen not only as a character but as a symbol of innocence destroyed by political and social chaos. Her story intersects with Anjum and Tilo’s lives, showing how the “shattered narrative” brings together multiple marginalized identities. By connecting Udaya Jebeen’s fate with larger social conflicts, Roy emphasizes that even the smallest, most silenced lives reveal the deepest truths about injustice and humanity.
A major symbolic focus in this video is the dung beetle, which represents the idea of turning decay into renewal. Roy uses this creature to show how the marginalized, like the beetle, transform what society discards into something meaningful and sustaining. The beetle becomes a metaphor for regeneration, endurance, and the cycle of life, especially within the graveyard where Anjum builds Jannat Guest House. This reflects Roy’s larger idea that life and hope can grow even from spaces associated with death and destruction.
The lecture further connects the dung beetle’s ecological importance with Roy’s political message: that those pushed to the margins still sustain the moral and social fabric of the nation. Just as the beetle restores balance in nature, Roy’s marginalized characters restore compassion and humanity in a fractured world. The symbol reinforces the theme that true paradise is not found in perfection, but in collective survival and acceptance.
Ultimately, this lecture interprets Udaya Jebeen and the dung beetle as twin symbols of hope and resilience in broken landscapes and broken lives. Roy’s narrative suggests that the novel is not hopeless; rather, it celebrates the power of inclusion, renewal, and the creation of belonging for those rejected by society. Through this, the lecture concludes that Roy transforms tragedy into a message of healing, dignity, and survival.
Main Points
-
Udaya Jebeen symbolizes abandoned and marginalized children.
-
Roy’s fragmented narrative connects her life with Anjum and Tilo.
-
The dung beetle represents renewal, resilience, and transformation.
-
Marginalized characters create their own inclusive paradise (Jannat).
-
The novel presents hope through survival, dignity, and regeneration.
Part 5 : Thematic study - The Ministry of Utmost Happiness
This part of the lecture series builds on earlier discussion of characters and places by focusing on the interwoven themes of identity, resistance, and redemption in Arundhati Roy’s The Ministry of Utmost Happiness. The lecture explains that the novel’s narrative uses personal stories of marginalised individuals to critique social exclusion and structural violence in India — including caste inequity, religious prejudice, gender discrimination, and state oppression. At the heart of this exploration is the idea that identity is fluid, contested, and shaped through both personal suffering and collective struggle.
The lecture highlights how characters like Anjum, Tilo, Musa, and Saddam represent different forms of resistance against dominant social forces. Anjum’s journey from a marginalized hijra to the caregiver of Jannat Guest House symbolizes self-creation and resilience in the face of exclusion. Meanwhile, Tilo and Musa’s involvement in the Kashmir conflict represents the intersection of personal longing and political resistance, showing how love and loss are both entangled with national struggle. Through these arcs, Roy suggests that resistance is not merely physical rebellion but also an assertion of dignity and self-worth.
A major focus in this lecture is how personal trauma becomes collective testimony in the narrative. For example, the found baby and Udaya Jebeen’s story — which represent abandonment and vulnerability — become narrative threads that connect individual suffering to larger questions of social injustice. This convergence of stories shows that the novel refuses simple closure, instead portraying identity as comprised of multiple intersecting histories. Roy’s approach reframes marginality not just as absence but as a source of profound insight and shared humanity.
The lecture also discusses the political context surrounding the novel’s events, emphasizing how Roy uses precise geopolitical settings — from Old Delhi’s graveyards to Kashmir and tribal regions — to illustrate the pervasiveness of violence, whether systemic or interpersonal. These spaces are not mere backdrops; they are charged landscapes that shape the characters’ identities and experiences. Roy’s narrative invites readers to consider how social structures like religion, caste, and nationalism contribute to both alienation and belonging.
Ultimately, this part of the lecture concludes that The Ministry of Utmost Happiness is a literary call to recognize shared humanity in places of fragmentation. Through its richly interconnected narratives of marginalised lives, the novel argues that true redemption lies in collective empathy, solidarity, and the courage to rewrite one’s identity against forces of exclusion. Roy’s work becomes not just a story about individual struggle, but a broader commentary on how societies can move toward inclusivity and justice.
Main Points:
- Identity in the novel is fluid, shaped by personal and political history.
- Resistance is portrayed not only as rebellion but as dignity and self-assertion.
- Individual trauma becomes collective testimony and shared experience.
- Geopolitical landscapes influence and reflect social marginalisation.
- Redemption comes through empathy, solidarity, and shared humanity.
The video begins by focusing on Hazrat Sarmad Shaheed, a historical figure and spiritual symbol in Arundhati Roy’s novel. Hazrat Sarmad’s shrine becomes a space where people of different faiths, genders, and identities converge. It is portrayed as a place of spiritual tolerance, freedom, and resistance against rigid societal norms. This symbol emphasizes that identity is not fixed and that individuals can seek truth beyond labels. The shrine is both a physical location and a metaphor for liberation and human connection.
Next, the video highlights Duniya and Jannat as central motifs. Duniya serves as a refuge for marginalized groups like the hijra community, illustrating a society outside traditional social hierarchies. Jannat, similarly, represents utopian possibilities and belonging that defy conventional boundaries of caste, class, and religion. Through these motifs, Roy conveys that happiness and community can exist in spaces beyond mainstream definitions of acceptance.
The video then explores the recurring color saffron, which is traditionally linked with Hindu nationalism. In the novel, saffron becomes a symbol of violence, exclusion, and political ideology. Its repeated appearance critiques how religious symbols are co-opted for power, reflecting the tension between culture, politics, and human rights. Saffron in this context shows the contrast between sacredness and political domination.
Another motif discussed in the video is cemeteries and graveyards. These spaces signify the intersection of life and death, and highlight how society often treats marginalized people as socially “dead” while they continue to live, resist, and form communities. Cemeteries in the narrative are liminal spaces where pain, hope, and resilience coexist, reinforcing the novel’s theme that happiness can arise even in the harshest conditions.
The video also emphasizes the nonlinear narrative structure of the novel. By weaving multiple timelines and perspectives, Roy mirrors the fragmented yet interconnected social and historical realities of India. This structure allows the reader to see how individual stories of love, loss, identity, and rebellion are intertwined with national conflicts and histories, making symbols and motifs not isolated elements but threads connecting personal and collective experiences.
In conclusion, the video illustrates that Arundhati Roy’s use of symbols and motifs — such as Hazrat Sarmad Shaheed, Duniya and Jannat, saffron, cemeteries, and the narrative structure — deepens the novel’s exploration of identity, belonging, resilience, and happiness. These literary tools help readers understand how marginalized lives negotiate space and meaning in a world marked by violence, exclusion, and social hierarchy. The motifs act as both literal and metaphorical spaces for resistance, hope, and freedom.
Main Points:
- Hazrat Sarmad Shaheed symbolizes spiritual freedom and resistance to rigid identity definitions.
- Duniya and Jannat represent inclusive communities and utopian spaces beyond caste and religion.
- The color saffron signifies political violence, ideological control, and exclusion.
- Cemeteries and graveyards highlight life, death, pain, and resilience.
- Nonlinear narrative connects personal stories with larger social and historical realities.
- Overall, symbols and motifs explore identity, marginalization, resistance, and redefined happiness.
Activity - A
Textual Analysis: Narrative Structure in The Ministry of Utmost Happiness(ChatGPT)
Arundhati Roy’s The Ministry of Utmost Happiness employs a deliberately fragmented, non-linear narrative structure that mirrors the psychological, social, and political trauma of its characters. Rather than presenting events chronologically, Roy constructs the novel as a series of interwoven life-stories that move across time, space, and identity. This narrative method reflects the idea that a “shattered story” can only be told by gradually becoming everything—absorbing multiple voices, experiences, and perspectives. The structure itself becomes an act of resistance against traditional storytelling, much like the characters resist fixed identities imposed by society.
Roy’s shifting timeline reflects the emotional and existential disintegration of individuals living on the margins. The narrative opens in the Khwabgah of Old Delhi, where Anjum’s early life unfolds in a community of hijras who exist outside mainstream social norms. However, this space of belonging collapses after the Gujarat riots, and the narrative abruptly moves Anjum into the graveyard (Jannat Guest House). This transition is symbolic: it reflects how trauma fractures both time and identity. The move from Khwabgah to the graveyard demonstrates how Anjum’s life shifts from a place of dreamlike acceptance (“Khwab”) to a space that represents death, loss, and rebirth. The non-linear storytelling captures Anjum’s emotional fragmentation and the way trauma erases continuity in her life.
The novel’s structure also connects Anjum’s Delhi narrative to Tilo’s Kashmir narrative, showing how trauma unites characters across geography and ideology. Tilo’s experiences in Kashmir—where she witnesses military violence, insurgency, and displacement—are narrated through a similarly disjointed timeline. Roy does not present Kashmir as a separate subplot but as a parallel world of shattered lives, mirroring Anjum’s struggles. The connection becomes explicit through the found baby, whom Anjum and Tilo eventually share responsibility for. This baby symbolizes not only innocence but also the fragile thread that binds fragmented narratives. Through this shared child, Roy demonstrates how personal trauma and political trauma intersect, creating a collective story of survival and hope.
The non-linear structure thus embodies the phrase “How to tell a shattered story by slowly becoming everything.” Roy allows the novel to absorb diverse histories—religious, gendered, political, and emotional—so that the narrative itself becomes a space of inclusivity. Each character’s broken experience contributes to a larger mosaic of resistance and belonging. Instead of one unified storyline, the novel presents a polyphonic structure, where trauma reshapes memory, identity, and narrative form. The disjointed chronology forces readers to confront the instability of reality itself, reflecting the instability of the characters’ worlds.
Ultimately, Roy’s narrative method suggests that healing and wholeness emerge from fragmentation rather than order. By allowing shattered voices to coexist, the novel transforms trauma into meaning and connection. The structure becomes an ethical statement: in a world fractured by violence and exclusion, stories must be told in ways that reflect that brokenness. Through her layered and non-linear storytelling, Roy shows that the only way to narrate a shattered world is by embracing multiplicity, empathy, and transformation.
Key Evidence :
-
Transition from Khwabgah (Old Delhi) → Graveyard (Jannat Guest House) reflects Anjum’s trauma after the Gujarat riots.
-
Tilo’s Kashmir narrative connects to Anjum’s Delhi story through the found baby.
-
The fragmented storytelling symbolizes the broken identities and social displacement of characters.
-
Roy’s narrative becomes a metaphor for becoming everything to tell the truth of a shattered world.
Activity B:
Mapping the Conflict (Mind Mapping with NotebookLM)
Connections Between Anjum, Saddam Hussain, and Tilo :
In The Ministry of Utmost Happiness, Arundhati Roy interlinks the lives of Anjum, Saddam Hussain, and Tilo through the shared experience of exclusion, violence, and survival in a fractured India. Though their stories unfold in different regions—Old Delhi, the mortuary, and Kashmir—they converge in the graveyard sanctuary called Jannat Guest House, which becomes a symbolic “Ministry of Utmost Happiness” for society’s outcasts.
Anjum, born as Aftab, represents gender and religious marginalization. Her trauma after the Gujarat massacre of 2002 shatters her identity and belonging. Unable to live in the Khwabgah again, she chooses the graveyard as her new home. By establishing the Jannat Guest House, Anjum converts a place of death into a space of life, dignity, and healing, symbolizing Roy’s vision of alternative belonging beyond societal and religious norms.
Saddam Hussain, originally Dayachand, represents Dalit identity and caste oppression. His father’s lynching under the pretext of cow-protection violence reflects the brutality of social and political systems. Working in the hospital’s mortuary, Saddam exists literally between life and death, mirroring Anjum’s liminal existence in the graveyard. Their bond grows from shared trauma, and eventually becomes familial when Saddam marries Zainab, Anjum’s adopted daughter, creating a new form of chosen kinship.
Tilo, an architect and activist, embodies the political and emotional trauma of Kashmir. Her fragmented narrative parallels Anjum’s shattered identity. Through the found baby at Jantar Mantar, Tilo’s story connects with the graveyard world. Saddam helps her and the child reach Jannat, symbolizing how Roy’s “shattered stories” of the marginalized are slowly woven together into one larger narrative of survival and resistance.
Together, these characters belong to what Roy calls the “other world” (Duniya of the marginalized). They are “falling people” who hold onto each other for survival. The graveyard thus becomes a place where the living, the socially dead, and the politically displaced coexist, challenging the dominant idea of who deserves life, dignity, and happiness.
By the end of the novel, Anjum, Saddam, and Tilo collectively transform the graveyard into a living paradise for the rejected. Their unity shows that utmost happiness is not an escape from trauma, but a shared act of rebuilding life in the ruins of violence.
Redefining “Jannat” (Paradise) in the Novel
Roy redefines Jannat (Paradise) as a space of ethical survival for the “living dead.” Instead of an afterlife reward, it becomes a physical and emotional sanctuary for those rejected by the nation, religion, caste, and gender.
Roy’s Jannat is not pure or heavenly—it is filled with ruins, graves, animals, pain, and survival, proving that paradise can exist even in the most broken spaces. It becomes a metaphor for a new India where coexistence, care, and resistance replace hierarchy and exclusion.
Main Analytical Points
Activity C:
Automated Timeline & Character Arcs (Auto-mode with Comet)
I. Anjum’s Journey: From Aftab to the Graveyard
II. Saddam Hussain’s Journey: From Witness to Meeting Anjum
Conclusion :
This activity helps us understand how Arundhati Roy connects different characters and places in The Ministry of Utmost Happiness to show the lives of marginalized people. Through NotebookLM, we see how Anjum, Saddam Hussain, and Tilo are linked by their experiences of violence, loss, and social rejection.
The idea of “Jannat” (Paradise) is redefined—not as a peaceful heaven for the dead, but as a space where the “living dead” find shelter and dignity. The graveyard becomes a symbol of resistance, survival, and belonging for those whom society has pushed aside.
Overall, this activity shows that the novel’s real “paradise” is a community built from pain, solidarity, and hope among the oppressed.
Activity D:
The "Audio/Video" Synthesis (Multimedia with NotebookLM)
This video
A key focus of the video is the symbolism of spaces in the novel, such as Khwabgah (the transgender community space), Jantar Mantar (site of protest), and Jannat Guest House (the graveyard community). These locations function as counter-spaces to mainstream society, each revealing different aspects of oppression and resistance. The video emphasizes that belonging and community must often be constructed outside the rigid structures of caste, state power, and capitalism, illustrating how these alternative spaces create identities and networks of support that challenge societal exclusion.
The video also highlights the novel’s non-linear narrative structure, showing how its fragmented storytelling mirrors the fragmented lives of the characters. Rather than following a single coherent timeline, the novel weaves multiple stories together to depict the interconnectedness of personal trauma, political conflict, and social exclusion. The video points out that this structure allows readers to experience the complexity of marginalization while understanding the characters’ struggles in a broader social and political context.
Finally, the video examines Roy’s use of symbolic images, such as the graveyard, the found baby, and the dung beetle, to redefine the concept of “paradise” (Jannat). In these images, spaces and creatures traditionally associated with neglect or death become sites of resilience, dignity, and renewal. The video argues that the novel shows how true belonging and meaning emerge through solidarity, empathy, and resistance to structures that marginalize and erase human lives, suggesting that happiness and community are created in the stories of those society often leaves behind.
In The Ministry of Utmost Happiness, Arundhati Roy examines the human cost of modernization, revealing how the external world—Dunya, shaped by material progress, nationalism, capitalism, and state authority—systematically marginalizes and dehumanizes those who do not conform to its ideals. The promise of development in modern India is depicted as a structure built on violence, exclusion, and social hierarchies, leaving many characters feeling internally displaced even while physically present within the nation. Against this backdrop, Roy brings the inner lives of her characters to the forefront, exploring how memory, trauma, belief, and survival persist beyond the logic of productivity, efficiency, and societal success imposed by modernity.
A central symbol in the novel, the Dung Beetle, represents resilience and endurance. Thriving on waste and decay, it embodies marginalized communities who survive on what society discards—materially, culturally, and socially. Rather than being a figure of degradation, the beetle transforms what is rejected into continuity and life, reflecting an alternative ethic of survival that challenges capitalist ideas of value and purity. In this way, the Dung Beetle mirrors the novel’s characters, who adapt, endure, and reconstruct their lives despite exclusion, trauma, and loss.
The graveyard, particularly Anjum’s Jannat Guest House, operates as another crucial symbol and counter-space to Dunya. While traditionally associated with death and abandonment, it becomes a haven of inclusive living, welcoming hijras, Dalits, Muslims, abandoned children, and political outsiders. Unlike cities dominated by surveillance, borders, and rigid hierarchies, the graveyard allows coexistence without the imposition of identity, status, or nationalist allegiance. By situating hope and community among the dead rather than within modern institutions, Roy emphasizes that genuine belonging and ethical solidarity are often forged outside the oppressive structures of contemporary society.
Together, the Dung Beetle and the graveyard subvert the notion of progress propagated by Dunya. They highlight that survival, dignity, and meaningful coexistence do not emerge from grand narratives of modernization, but from marginal spaces where life continues quietly, inclusively, and resiliently despite systemic neglect. Through these symbols, the novel underscores how those excluded from mainstream society cultivate their own forms of community, resilience, and ethical belonging.
Ultimately, Roy’s narrative invites readers to rethink the meaning of happiness and belonging. True fulfillment, the video argues, is found not in the promises of development and modernization, but in the solidarity, empathy, and quiet resistance demonstrated by marginalized lives. The novel asserts that resilience, dignity, and communal bonds flourish in spaces that society overlooks, reminding us that life and meaning often emerge where we least expect them.
References :
Barad, D. (2026). Flipped Learning Worksheet on The Ministry of Utmost Happiness. ResearchGate. https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.2.19004.09607
DoE-MKBU. (2021, December 28). Part 1 | Khwabgah | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness | Arundhati Roy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-29vE53apGs
DoE-MKBU. (2021b, December 28). Part 2 | Jantar Mantar | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness | Arundhati Roy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gr1z1AEXPBU
DoE-MKBU. (2021c, December 28). Part 3 | Kashmir and Dandakaranyak | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness | Arundhati Roy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIKH_89rML0
DoE-MKBU. (2021d, December 28). Part 4 | Udaya Jebeen & Dung Beetle | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness | Arundhati Roy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VH5EULOFP4g
DoE-MKBU. (2021e, December 30). Thematic Study | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness | Arundhati Roy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NYSTUTBoSs
DoE-MKBU. (2021e, December 30). Symbols and Motifs | The Ministry of Utmost Happiness | Arundhati Roy [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbBOqLB487U
Thank You!
.png)
No comments:
Post a Comment